Tuesday, January 31, 2012

Merkel takes the fight directly to Hollande

The politics of the eurozone crisis took several new twists and turns over the weekend, including the news that Angela Merkel intends to step in and “actively” support Nicolas Sarkozy’s Presidential re-election campaign (although he is yet to formally announce his candidature) against the Socialist candidate Francois Hollande. It is understood this involvement could take the form of joint campaign appearances.

Moreover, Hermann Gröhe, a senior member of Merkel’s CDU party did not mince his words when he commented on the election, claiming that:
“[Sarkozy] is the right man in the Elysée now and in the future…We need a strong France with a strong president in charge…The Socialists are stuck in their dreams of the past. All they are doing is bringing out dusty concepts and wealth distribution fantasies from their moth-ridden policy cupboard.”
In recent months, Hollande’s candidacy has become the focal point of opposition to Merkel’s crisis management strategy and the ethos that underpins it - symbolised by the treaty on closer fiscal integration and discipline. Hollande has promised to focus less on austerity and more on promoting jobs and growth, both in France and the eurozone; he has pledged, if elected, to re-negotiate the treaty so that it focuses less on 'stability' and more on 'solidarity'. Although Sarkozy signed up to the treaty at yesterday's summit, the French parliament will not have an opportunity to ratify it before the presidential elections.

The stakes are therefore high for Merkel who has a lot political capital – both domestically and internationally - riding on the successful transposition of the treaty into domestic law throughout the eurozone (even if it is debatable as to whether it will address the root causes of the crisis). Given that polls consistently give Hollande a clear lead, Merkel has decided that in order to protect the treaty in its current state, she will have to intervene. While it may be unpopular with her own MPs who consider it to have been watered down too much, she knows this is nothing compared to how it would be affected by a likely Hollande victory.

The big question is whether Merkel's endorsement will be to Sarkozy's benefit or detriment; it certainly jars with his recent media strategy of playing the humble do-gooder trying to make the best out of a bad situation. It is likewise no secret that due to Merkel's (perceived) lack of willingness to compromise on issues such as eurobonds or the ECB, both she and Germany as a whole have become the pantomime villains of the crisis. There is also potentially the risk of a backlash against Sarkozy if the French public feels that Merkel has crossed the line and is actively trying to meddle in their domestic political arrangements.

Ultimately however, both Merkel and Sarkozy will hope that as suggested in the FT’s editorial this weekend, the French public will vote with their hearts in the first round, and with their heads in the second. While they cannot win in the popularity stakes, they will count on the fact that the public will at least recognise that they have taken tough but necessary action to tackle the eurozone crisis, and that for all his rhetoric, Hollande lacks a credible plan for making the French economy competitive. There are some grounds for optimism - a poll earlier this month found that 82% of respondents had a positive view of Germany, in particular regarding its leadership and work ethic. Finally, it is worth remembering Merkel is not renowned as an astute political operator for nothing; evidently she has decided Sarkozy's re-election is not a lost cause.

Merkel's intervention should add further spice to what is shaping up to be a fascinating election campaign - as ever we will keep you updated on the ins and outs...

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

The best thing that Sarkozy can do is keep Merkel away from France during the elections.

The French by and large do not like or trust her, but that is the same in many EU countries now.

He needs her to campaign for him like he needs a hole in the head.

Rollo said...

Both Sarkosy and Merkel have loved this image of the German Eagle and the French Cock wing on wing straddling Europe and standing high in the world. They need to stay wing in wing to maintain the illusion.
Of course most people remember the French Poule lying flat on her back being straddled by the German Eagle, and it beomes more apparent daily that that is the real relationship.
Germany has sucked France dry. You only have to look at the graphs of French exports to Germany and German exports to France to realise the strong downward descent, accelerating in the Sarkosy years.

Rik said...

Hollande is likely an even bigger disaster than Sarko, but agree with anonymous that this is very likely not to work.
Likely the French do not go for it as they want to decide simply for themselves and not by being told by a foreigner.
Well as the average politician that got the question if voters see them as natural leaders or as the least dangerous pest available wrong.

Christina Speight said...

It used to be near-prohibition that any politician interfered in the elections in another country! who does Merkel think she is to break this long-standing rule?

She will have enough problems at home with the ECB lending on a huge scale and at 1% interest to eurozone banks. The figure quoted is 1 trillion euros. Surely this will cause uncontrolled inflation across the EU and especially in Germany where that matters.